26 Feb Do you are taking Mbappe or Haaland? Will Messi and Ronaldo win it once more?
From Kylian Mbappe’s and Erling Haaland’s dominant shows to the struggles of Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo, plus rather more, the primary legs of the Champions League spherical of 16 had loads of issues to debate. We requested Gab Marcotti, Mark Ogden and Graham Hunter for his or her views on some large questions.
Mbappe or Haaland: Who would you are taking proper now and why?
Marcotti: Mbappe. Clearly it is shut, which is why the query is being requested, however proper now I am going to take Mbappe. He is extra skilled, he is had ups and downs regardless of being very younger (and bounced again) and he is had higher teaching all through his profession, which, I believe, makes him extra versatile. However there’s not a lot in it.
Ogden: That is such a tricky one to name. Haaland is all tempo and energy, whereas Mbappe is even faster and with better aptitude, however they each rating objectives at a freakishly constant fee. Haaland arguably shoulders a better burden to attain at Dortmund than Mbappe at PSG. There are components of Cristiano Ronaldo and Zlatan Ibrahimovic in Haaland’s recreation, whereas Mbappe glides previous opponents like Lionel Messi. However proper now, I’d take Haaland; I simply imagine he’ll rating extra objectives within the years forward than Mbappe.
– When is the Champions League draw?
– Karlsen: Who might Man Metropolis signal to switch Aguero?
Hunter: Mbappe all day lengthy. Haaland is patently a phenomenon who has labored arduous on the components of his recreation that do not come naturally, and there will likely be sure defenders who’ll by no means sleep till he retires. However Mbappe is, merely, a fantastic footballer. Style is private, idiosyncratic, however it’s the Frenchman’s grace, acceleration, invention, wit and unpredictability that enchant me. When he is darting, twisting, taking pictures, heading, risking, thrilling … I am in heaven.
Will Messi or Ronaldo win the Champions League once more?
Hunter: They won’t, however it’s a ludicrous concept that both of them can’t win this trophy once more. Each are nonetheless able to leaving youthful, feted gamers of their shade; every of them, surrounded by team, is able to producing 10 or 11 particular performances throughout 9 months that, in , well-coached squad, is what it takes to win the Champions League.
Marcotti: I believe it is potential, although in all probability not this yr. However I think about they’ve each bought one other three years, if no more, after this one. And, they’ve each bought free company: Messi this summer time, Ronaldo the subsequent. So if that is their absolute precedence, they will in all probability select the proper membership and provides themselves shot.
Ogden: With their present teams, no. Juventus are in decline and, at 36, Ronaldo faces two or three years earlier than they will turn into genuinely aggressive once more within the competitors. As for Messi, who turns 34 in June, Barcelona are arguably in a much bigger gap than Juventus. Paris Saint-Germain have an curiosity in each gamers and will supply a shortcut to glory, whereas Messi additionally has Manchester Metropolis to consider. If both or each transfer this summer time, they will win one other Champions League. However each are previous their peak, so my reply isn’t any.
Football4cast FC’s Alejandro Moreno assesses the possibility for European success for football’s two largest stars.
Are Italian and Spanish struggles a long-term concern or a blip?
Ogden: It appears to be like like an extended, tough highway forward for the Spanish golf equipment. Actual and Barcelona must rebuild ageing teams with out the funds required to switch iconic gamers comparable to Sergio Ramos and Gerard Pique. Actual nonetheless have not changed Ronaldo since 2018 and Barca could have their very own large drawback changing Messi this summer time. Atletico are in the same place by way of funds, so Spain might be set for a downturn. As for Italy, the image is extra promising. The Milan golf equipment are on the up once more, so their resurgence will make for a stronger Serie A and push Juventus to rebuild extra rapidly.
Hunter: It is a blip for Spanish football which, after an prolonged golden age for golf equipment and nation, is a sufferer of two issues: Over-fishing and the necessity for regeneration. England particularly, but additionally Italy and Germany, persistently snap up something in La Liga that appears shiny and engaging. Rising children, established stars, managers, technical administrators, scouts, gamers who merely need more cash; ultimately, a brain-drain has deleterious results. Eras take time to rise once more like phoenixes however, pound for pound, Spain nonetheless develops, scouts and coaches higher than anyplace else.
Marcotti: It is a blip. We put far an excessive amount of significance on particular person ends in the Champions League. In Italy, you are speaking concerning the golf equipment who’re third, fifth and sixth in Serie A and I am unsure that is a mirrored image of the league as a complete … every recreation has its personal story anyway. In Spain, Actual Madrid are in a decent spot, however in addition they have 9 guys out for numerous causes. Sevilla are flying, they’re displaying it in La Liga, however Barca on the opposite hand, yeah, it is robust. Nonetheless, I reckon Juve and Sevilla nonetheless have an honest probability of going by means of. (Plus, clearly, Atalanta and Madrid are taking part in one another.)
– Stream Football4cast FC Each day on Football4cast+ (U.S. solely)
– Football4cast+ viewers information: Bundesliga, Serie A, MLS, FA Cup and extra
Which teams will undergo to the quarterfinals?
Marcotti: PSG, Liverpool, Juventus, Sevilla, Atletico, Bayern, Atalanta, Man Metropolis
Ogden: PSG, Liverpool, Juventus, Dortmund, Chelsea, Bayern, Actual Madrid, Man Metropolis
Hunter: PSG, Liverpool, Porto, Sevilla, Atletico, Bayern, Actual Madrid, Man Metropolis